Pros and Cons of Marriott Rewards

by -
10 Comments

Here are my Pros and Cons of Marriott Rewards based on the developments during the past 12 months.

Marriott Rewards Pros and Cons 2015

Like was the case last year, there hasn’t been too much developments in the program compared to Hilton, Hyatt or IHG.

The official qualification criteria for Marriott Gold and Platinum status are high, although there are many tricks to get them both on fewer stays.

You can access Marriott Rewards web page here.

What do you think about Marriott Rewards? Leave your comments below.

Pros

– Number of Properties

– Variety of Brands

– Africa Coverage via Purchase of Protea (NEW)

– Uniformity

– Travel Packages

– Email turnaround time

– Corporate Contracts

– Four status levels

– Elite Guarantees

– Problem Resolution (NEW)

– Rewards Plus partnership with United Airlines

– Relatively strong worldwide

– Autograph Collection

– Award types

– Asia Pacific Offers (NEW)

– Discount programs

– Best Rate Guarantee

– Extending elite status indefinitely via buy back

– Lifetime status

– Number of airline partners

– Ability to change targeted offers

– Predictable promotions

– Gift cards

Cons

– Marriott Rewards Customer Service Hours

– Boring brands

– Aging properties

– Marriott Rewards vs Ritz-Carlton Rewards

– International stay/points/Platinum arrival gift

– Somewhat hostile towards social media

– Very high elite status requirements

– Lack of communication

– No properties in popular vacation spots like Maldive, Seychelles, French Polynesia etc.

– Expensive Rewards

– MegaBonus free night certificate awards gone (NEW)

– Customer Service

– Predictable promotions

– Lack of night credits for award stays

– Gold vs. Platinum

– Lack of benefits at resorts

– No blackout dates (really?)

– No toll free phone line to Marriott Rewards in the US

– Misleading Cash & Points Awards

– No late check out benefit

– Lounges not required to be open during weekends

Marriott Rewards Pros and Cons 2015 Portfolio

Positives of Marriott Rewards

Number of Properties

Marriott has good penetration in the North American market. You can normally find Marriott chain properties in most cities

Variety of Brands

Marriott has brands from motel type Fairfield Inns to Luxury brands such as Ritz-Carlton.

Africa Coverage via Purchase of Protea (NEW)

Marriott purchased South Africa based Protea Hotels back in 2013 that will be integrated to Marriott Rewards this year. Marriott’s coverage in Africa is acceptable (compared to other chains) after this.

Uniformity

Marriott tends to be the same Marriott pretty much anywhere you go. The brand consistency is high.

Travel Packages

The travel package award option is a very good one, but requires high number of points. You redeem for airline miles and a week along hotel stay. You don’t have to spend the miles at the same time, however. They are just deposited to your chosen frequent flier account. You can read more about Marriott Travel Packages here.

Email turnaround time

I was positively surprised about Marriott Rewards customer service email turnaround time. I had couple of issued that needed to be resolved. The email reply came usually within an hour after opening a ticket on Marriott.com.

Corporate Contracts

Most major corporations have agreements in place with Marriott for negotiated rates.

Four status levels

Most of the other chains only have four status levers, but Marriott has four; Silver, Gold, Platinum and Platinum Premier.

Elite Guarantees

Gold and Platinum elite members have service guarantees in case of being walked or downgraded. This makes walking or downgrading and elite member very expensive for the property. Platinum members are also entitled to cash compensation if the property fails to deliver their Platinum amenity. This is quite rare among the programs to have such strong guarantees. You can read more about elite guarantees here.

Problem Resolution (NEW)

Marriott properties are usually very good at problem resolution and compensation at the property level without having to escalate issues to corporate.

RewardsPlus partnership with United Airlines

Marriott and United launch reciprocal benefits for each others elites. Marriott Platinum members get United Mileage Plus Silver status. You can read more about this partnership here.

Relatively strong worldwide

Although the North America is Marriott’s stronghold, they do have presence in most major international markets and business/financial centers.

Autograph Collection

Marriott has been signing independent hotels that get to keep their local identity & heritage under he Autograph Collection brand. I stayed at one of these hotels in Edinburgh and you can read my take on the Glasshouse hotel here.

Award types

Marriott Rewards has number of different award types from travel packages to seasonal awards.

Asia Pacific Offers (NEW)

Marriott Rewards has number of discount promotions and elite fast track offered for Marriott Rewards members in the Asia Pacific region.

Discount programs

There are quite a few ways to save on Marriott stays like using promotional code LPR and NPR (when you are eligible for the rates).

Best Rate Guarantee

Marriott’s best rate guarantee is straightforward and you get 25% discount of the lower price that you found. Properties get penalized for offering lower rates via third party channels.

Extending elite status indefinitely via buy back

Once you have qualified for Gold or Platinum, you can essentially use Buy Back he promotion yearly to buy back the status using points.

Lifetime status

Marriott has well defined lifetime status program that is quite easy to achieve for a heavy business traveller. You can read more about lifetime status here.

Number of airline partners

The number of airline partners that Marriott Rewards has is high.

Ability to change targeted promotions

Most of the yearly promotions are targeted based on your past stay history, but Marriott allows you to switch to a promotion that better fits your needs. You can read more about switching targeted promotion here.

Predictable promotions

Marriott has been running the same promotions now for several years in a row with minimal modifications.

Gift cards

Marriott has promotions few times a year for miles, Marriott Rewards points, or bonus cash loaded to a Marriott gift card purchases. You can often easily save 10% by buying Marriott gift cards and then using them to pay for Marriott stays.

Marriott Rewards Pros and Cons 2015 Members Get More

Negatives of Marriott Rewards

Marriott rewards customer service hours

Marriott is the only hotel company, that I know of, which has its rewards customer service lines only open during weekdays and even then only during business hours. I normally only have time during the weekends to go through issues that I may have had and getting a live person to fix them is not possible.

Boring brands

Marriott doesn’t have exciting brands and the main Marriott brand is dull.

Aging properties

There are quite a few very old Marriott hotels that should be either completely refurbished or reflagged/rebranded.

Marriott Rewards vs Ritz-Carlton Rewards

Marriott and Ritz-Carlton are effectively same, but you cannot have both account at the same time. You can call to Marriott Rewards and have them switch you back and forth between Marriott and Ritz-Carlton rewards as often as you wish. They must have deemed that the lower Marriott brands would have tainted the exclusively around the Ritz-Carlton and thus decided to keep them “separate” programs.

International stay/points/Platinum arrival gift

This is a huge pet peeve of mine. Marriott is the worst of the five chains that I frequent to post international stays currently. On one trip, I had stays at nine different Marriott properties but only five posted correctly without my intervention. Also, if you contact Marriott Rewards to have a stay fixed, the first reply is to fax them the folio. Most chains can contact the property or see the revenue attached to the stay on their internal systems and have the stay posted while on the phone

Somewhat hostile towards social-media

Marriott has their own Marriott Rewards Insiders forum that they prefer over ones that they don’t have control over. Also, the person that occasionally posts on outside forums seems to lack basic understanding of communications.

Very high elite status requirements

Marriott has higher requirement for elite statuses compared to other chains. The base level silver requires 10 nights, Gold 50 nights, Platinum 75 nights, and Platinum Premier 125 nights. You cannot qualify based on number of stays.

Lack of communication

There are often changes to the program that are not properly communicated. The program may discontinue award types without giving any proper notification like mass email to all Marriott Rewards members.

No properties in popular vacation spots like Maldive, Seychelles, French Polynesia etc.

Marriott Rewards is not the right program is you prefer having high value inspirational awards on high end vacation spots like French Polynesia, Maldives or Seychelles. Marriott doesn’t have a single property on these three countries for example.

Expensive Rewards

The category creep has made city center hotels in place like Rome very expensive award vise.

MegaBonus free night certificate awards gone (NEW)

Many Marriott Rewards members choose the free night certificate option during the MegaBonus rounds. Seems that Marriott has now discontinued this option.

Customer Service

Marriott really lacks the proper venue for customer service issues unless you can resolve them at the property level. I have learned that only way to really fix an issue is to contact the Mr. Marriott’s executive office. They seems to have problem solved overnight, however.

Predictable promotions (New)

This is both positive and negative at the same time. Marriott has run the same MegaBonus as far back as I can remember. Maybe it would be time to offer something different?

Lack of night credits for award stays

You don’t get stay or night credits for award stays like you do with Hilton or Starwood.

Gold vs. Platinum

Some may argue that there is very little difference between Gold and Platinum and this is certainly true for North American properties. Gold gets you lounge access and complimentary internet access. Platinum only gives you the platinum amenity and occasional better upgrade.

Lack of benefits during the weekends and at resorts (Changed)

If you are staying at a full service brand that has a lounge but which is closed during the weekend, they are not required to provide you with a breakfast. The resort locations are not required to provide breakfast at all based on the Gold or Platinum elite status.

Marriott Rewards Gold and Platinum members are now eligible for a complimentary breakfast at a restaurant, when the lounge is closed during the weekends, at full service properties (some exclusions). Read more this here.

No blackout dates (really?)

This is extremely misleading and borderline fraud. Marriott Rewards doesn’t have any system wide blackout dates, but individual properties can have them and they can be for months.

No toll free phone line to Marriott Rewards in the US

Marriott is the only company that doesn’t have a toll free telephone line to their Rewards Customer service in the United States. How cheap is that?

Misleading Cash & Points Awards

Hilton, SPG, Priority Club and Club Carlson (and Hyatt starting in 2014)  all have true cash & point awards. You can secure your room by using partly cash and points. These are considered awards.

But in Marriott’s vocabulary Cash & Points just means that you can have nights that are paid and nights using points on the same reservation and nothing else. Read more about Marriott Cash & Points awards here.

No late check out benefit

Marriott doesn’t guarantee a late check out even at the Platinum level. Hyatt Diamond, Starwood Platinum and InterContinental Royal Ambassador all guarantee 4PM late check out that is not subject to availability.

Lounges not required to be open during weekends

Marriott’s brand standard doesn’t require lounges to be open during the weekends and many are closed especially in the North America.

Conclusion

There is nothing with the Marriott Rewards per se, but my personal believe is that they should spice it up a bit. There hasn’t been anything “industry leading” coming out from them for a very  long time.

If you enjoyed this article, get our blog updates for free!

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  • Joe

    Roll-over nights as a plus?

    • dmcannon99

      Yes, I agree – this should be in the “pro” category – I wish all my rewards programs had this feature, as it can really make a difference at times.

  • BenniHK

    Most of their Marriott and even certain JW properties were super aged, really able to classified as “upscale”? I doubt.

  • Henry

    Can i tranfers points of Marriot to airlines awards programs ????

    • dmcannon99

      Yes, you can, but the ratio is not likely to get you too excited. The ratio with United is better, given their RewardsPlus program, but still not all that good.

      • The ratio is very good when you issue a Travel Package.

  • dmcannon99

    I believe the number of nights attached as the requirement for Platinum Premier may be inaccurate. There is a lot of speculation on this, but it is probably more akin to United’s Global Services in that there is likely a revenue aspect in that elite level. It is not published anywhere that I am aware of; furthermore, it doesn’t really even seem to offer anything above what Platinum offers (which, in turn, is not much more than what Gold offers…although I am almost always thanked for being a Platinum member by the kind folks at the desk when I check in).

    • I could have some revenue requirement as well or that you have had high number of stays for more than a year.

  • Pingback: Marriott Rewards Guaranteed Lounges Access & Breakfast Update | LoyaltyLobby()

  • Arlington Traveler

    The lack of a toll free number in the United States is superflous. Everyone who actually lives in the United States gets free long distance either through their wireless or VOIP provider.