It is time for the Pros and Cons of hotel loyalty programs 2014 update, and I will start it off with the Le Club Accorhotels that I have not included previously.
I didn’t want to include the program in the previous years, as I hadn’t had too much stay experience with them. This year, however, I had close to 20 nights during the last 3 months due to lucrative promotions.
You can access Le Club Accorhotels web page for benefits here.
Please leave your personal comments about the Le Club Accorhotels programs below. What do you like and what do you dislike?
– Number of properties in Europe (especially in France) and Asia
– Strong at the lower end of properties
– No credit card link up
– Good 40% off sales throughout the year
– Accor Advantage Plus discount of 10% in Asia Pacific
– Platinum status for Amex cardholders in certain markets
– Easy status qualification
– Points earnings
– Never ending promotions
– Converting points to airline miles
– Platinum & Gold discount rate
– Weekend discounts in Latin America
– Truly no blackout dates
– Almost Non-existent properties in North America
– Fewer high end properties
– No credit card link up
– Getting stays to post
– Quality within the brands
– Calculating the number of points earned difficult
– Elite treatment
– Best rate guarantee
– Issues with promotions
– Excluded properties ibis budget and all ibis hotels in China
– No Status match
– Using points for free stays
– Very few guarantees based on availability
– The value of Euro vouchers converted at the property’s cash rate
– Customer service
– No lifetime status
Number of properties in Europe (especially in France) and Asia
Accor is especially strong in France and Europe representing 61% of the groups number of properties. Asia Pacific represents roughly quarter of the properties under the Accor’s umbrella.
Strong at the lower end properties
Sofitel, Pullman and MGallery brands represent less than 10% of the total number of hotels Accor has.
No credit card link up
Some may prefer that Accor doesn’t sell points to credit card partners.
Good 40% off sales throughout the year
Accor tend to have Super Sales several times year + up to 40% off Private Sales in between.
Accor Advantage Plus discount of 10% in Asia Pacific
You can purchase Accor Advantage Plus membership that gives you an additional 10% off of most rates in the Asia Pacific.
Platinum status for Amex cardholders in certain markets
Certain American Express cardholders in some markets are eligible for instant Platinum status with Le Club Accorhotels.
Easy status qualification
The number of nights and/or points required for Gold and Platinum status may initially look very high, but you can get Platinum status in just four or five stays if you time your stays with good airline related promotions.
You can earn points much faster by taking advantage of Le Club Accorhotels promotions.
Never ending promotions
Accor has so many on-going promotions for discounts, bonus miles and points that it is difficult to track them all (I am trying to do my very best here on LoyaltyLobby).
Converting points to airline miles
You can usually convert Le Club Accorhotels points to miles with 2 points to 1 airline miles ratio.
Platinum & Gold discount rate
Le Club Accorhotels members are sometimes eligible for discounts based on the elite level they have with the chain.
Weekend discounts in Latin America
Le Club Accorhotels elite members are eligible for 50% off rates for weekend stays in Latin America… that is a good deal.
Truly no blackout dates
You convert your Le Club Accorhotels points to EUR vouchers or use them online to guarantee your rooms. 2,000 points are worth 40 euros.
Almost Non-existent in North America
The chain has roughly 10 properties combined in the United States and Canada.
Fewer high end properties
Sofitel, MGallery and Pullman properties are considered the high end of Accor and there are fewer than 300 of them worldwide.
No credit card link up
Some prefer earning points towards free nights by charging their credit cards. This is not possible with Accor.
Getting stays to post
I have had a great difficulty getting paid stays to post from full service properties. I had had to chase more than 60% of these stays. Lower end properties seem to be able to handle the posting better.
Quality within the brands
This is not just a problem with Accor, but will all hotel chains. There is usually great variability within the brands.
Calculating the number of points earned difficult
Le Club Accorhotels can earn anywhere from 5 to 44 points per 10 euros charged depending on their status and brand stayed at. As a matter of fact there are 16 different levels altogether.
Obviously lower end properties don’t have too many options for upgrades, but you often must negotiate with higher end brands as well.
Best rate guarantee
Accor has a best rate guarantee that promises to match the lower price and to take an extra 10% off. The implementation of this program is terrible, however. Accor merely forwards the price match requests to individual properties that are then supposed to process and handle them. Sometimes the do and sometimes they don’t.
Issues with promotions
Accor’s promotions often require you to book within certain dates and sometimes also require you to book a specific rate. Sometimes promotions are retired without any word from Accor.
Excluded properties ibis budget and all ibis hotels in China
Many of the Accor hotels are excluded from earning points. You cannot earn points at any ibis hotels in China and ibis budget hotels are excluded worldwide.
No Status match
Le Club Accorhotels doesn’t offer status match, but you can easily get the Platinum status in few stays during the airline related promotions.
The communication from Accor regarding these promotions that they decide to end without any notice to membership is bizarre. It is very difficult to trust company that can cancel promos at their whim.
Using points for free stays
As you use vouchers to pay for your stay, you need lots of spend to get enough vouchers for a free night stay at the top end properties.
Very few guarantees based on availability
Le Club Accorhotels elite members have very few HARD guarantees. Most are based on the availability and/or at the discretion of the hotel in question.
The value of Euro vouchers converted at the property’s cash rate
Many hotels cheat and use their cash conversion rate when applying Accor voucher to your folio. You can lose anywhere from 5% to 20% of their value.
I have not had personal experience with the customer service, but some responses that I have seen from LoyaltyLobby readers are often rather cold. Sometimes they just ask if the member would prefer closing their account.
No lifetime status
Many of the Accor’s competitors offer lifetime status to those that have spent considerable time of their lives or cash at their properties. I am not aware of that Accor would be offering anything similar.
Le Club Accorhotels has both upped the number of points that member earn and spiced up the elite level benefits in the past 12 months trying to make the program more competitive. I just hope that they fix some of the issues that I have addressed above.
I have liked my stays at the Pullman and MGallery hotels. It is always good to have choices at the lower end too.