LoyaltyLobby
  • News
  • Hotel Promos
    • Accor
    • Best Western
    • Radisson Rewards
    • Choice
    • Fairmont
    • Hilton
    • World of Hyatt
    • IHG Rewards
    • Marriott
    • Ritz-Carlton
    • Starwood
    • Wyndham Rewards
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • Blog View
  •  
LoyaltyLobby
  • News
  • Hotel Promos
    • Accor
    • Best Western
    • Radisson Rewards
    • Choice
    • Fairmont
    • Hilton
    • World of Hyatt
    • IHG Rewards
    • Marriott
    • Ritz-Carlton
    • Starwood
    • Wyndham Rewards
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • Blog View
  •  
LoyaltyLobby
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

U.S. News & World Report Best Travel Rewards Programs 2015 – 2016

by John Ollila
August 5, 2015
Reading Time: 2 mins read
6

U.S. New & World Report released yesterday its annual Best Travel Rewards Programs that tries to compare airline and hotel loyalty programs and rank them.

US News & World Report Best Travel Rewards Programs

These rankings are for US based airlines and hotel loyalty programs and the methodology used for airline ranking is better than the one for hotel ones.

You can access U.S. News & World Reports web page for this study here.

ADVERTISEMENT

Airlines:

1. Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan (4.39)

2. American Airlines AAdvantage (4.04)

3. Southwest Rapid Rewards (3.99)

4. JetBlue TrueBlue (3.95)

5. HawaiianMiles (3.88)

6. Virgin America Elevate (3.61)

7. Frontier EarlyReturns (3.55)

8. United MileagePlus (3.45)

9. Delta SkyMiles (3.11)

10. FREE SPIRIT (1.16)

The ranking of American, United and Delta is correct here. You could argue that the order of the smaller airlines programs is fine too, but difficult to compare with the three network carriers and their alliances.

The study ranks smaller programs too high basically. There is nothing wrong with Alaska, Southwest, JetBlue etc. but they just cannot compete for international travel with the three network airlines.

Hotels:

1. Marriott Rewards (4.72)

2. Wyndham Rewards (4.22)

3. Best Western Rewards (4.09)

3. Club Carlson (4.09)

5. IHG Rewards Club (4.04)

6. Leaders Club (3.93)

7. La Quinta Returns (3.88)

8. Starwood Preferred Guest (3.86)

9. Hilton HHonors (3.78)

10. Hyatt Gold Passport (3.68)

11. Choice Privileges (3.09)

12. Stash Hotel Rewards (2.88)

13. Omni Select Guest (2.73)

14. Kimpton Karma Rewards (2.72)

15. Le Club Accorhotels (2.10)

16. Fairmont President’s Club (2.01)

17. iPrefer (1.98)

18. Loews YouFirst (1.59)

Here’s where I am starting to have an issue with these rankings. Marriott Rewards should simply not be in the first spot due to its deceptive marketing practices when it comes to free nights. The program advertises that there are no blackout dates even when properties can have them.

Also, the award inventory is not tied to the base level room. It is difficult to redeem at popular destinations due to no award rooms being available when hotels continue to offer base level rooms for sale.

The study doesn’t take into account promotions that the hotel chains are offering that helps with accumulation of free nights and points boost from using affiliated credit card for paying stays.

Wyndham and Best Western rank very high, although their programs offer very little in the form of status recognition for frequent travelers and lack of quality properties.

I stopped covering the iPrefer last year when I calculated that you need 50 nights to earn one free night with the program. Why even bother at that point?

Le Club Accorhotels should be much higher considering the number of points that you earn for your stays and the ease of turning them to the free nights. Probably the lack of properties in North America has lead to this low ranking of them.

Methodology used:

Download (PDF, 96KB)

Conclusion

The study does rank the US network carriers in the right order but fails in the hotel sector due to difficulty trying to rank the programs to the depth required.

I really should update my study of hotel loyalty programs that I did two years ago (did take too much time) to update the average $$$ required to get a free night in number of these programs (access the 2013 finding here).

Previous Post

REMINDER: Hilton HHonors Caribbean 4th Night Free & $100 Resort Credit Summer Sale For Stays Until September 30, 2015

Next Post

Cathay Pacific: 20% Redemption Promotion Between HKG and Selected Cities in Taiwan & Japan (Book by 19 Aug 2015)

Related Articles

Are You Going To Change Your Credit Card, Hotel, or Frequent Flyer Program This Year?

Are You Going To Change Your Credit Card, Hotel, or Frequent Flyer Program This Year?

Sebastian Powell
January 17, 2023
35

The new calendar year just started, and most loyalty counters of the various hotel and airline programs have reset to...

U.S. Domestic Flights Heavily Delayed Or Cancelled Due To FAA System Failure, Grounding Flight Operations

U.S. Domestic Flights Heavily Delayed Or Cancelled Due To FAA System Failure, Grounding Flight Operations

Sebastian Powell
January 11, 2023
1

The United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) is currently experiencing a systems outage that's causing nationwide grounding of domestic flight...

U.S. Airlines Are Extending Their Cancellations To Mainland China & Hong Kong Until Late April

Hong Kong Removes Restrictions For International Travelers Including “Amber” Health Code Period From December 14, 2022

Sebastian Powell
December 13, 2022
8

The government of Hong Kong has just announced that effective Wednesday, December 14th 2022, almost all restrictions for international travelers...

Upgrade Your Travel IQ

Make the most of your travel with our free and daily newsletter with the latest hotel and airline news and promotions.

We do not sell or share email addresses.

ADVERTISEMENT

Trending

Hilton Go Employee And Friends & Family Rate Plans
Hilton Honors

Hilton Go Employee And Friends & Family Rate Plans

July 25, 2021
UPDATE: Hilton Honors “Tier Last Call 2023 Promotion – Fast Track“ January 1 – March 31, 2023 (Updated Links )
Hilton Honors

UPDATE: Hilton Honors “Tier Last Call 2023 Promotion – Fast Track“ January 1 – March 31, 2023 (Updated Links )

January 26, 2023
Japan Entry Experience Through Sapporo’s New Chitose Airport January 2023
Travel News

Japan Entry Experience Through Sapporo’s New Chitose Airport January 2023

January 25, 2023
German Members Of Parliament No Longer Receive Complimentary Lufthansa Senator Status As Of This Year
Lufthansa - Miles & More

Lufthansa Miles&More Offers One Year Senator Extensions For 1400 Euro, Free In Greater China

January 26, 2023
Go Hilton Employee And Friends & Family Rate Plan Changes For 2022
Hilton Honors

Go Hilton Employee And Friends & Family Rate Plan Changes For 2022

January 17, 2022

Top Categories

  • IHG Rewards Club
  • Marriott Bonvoy
  • Hilton Honors
  • Accor ALL
  • Airfare Of The Day
  • Starwood Preferred Guest (SPG)
  • Hyatt – World of Hyatt
  • Travel News
  • American Airlines – AAdvantage
  • British Airways
ADVERTISEMENT

All Categories

In Case You Missed It

Reader Question: When Do Marriott Bonvoy’s 2,000 Bonus Points Per Brand For Co-Branded Cards Post?

Marriott Bonvoy Has Finally Posted Some Of The Fall/Winter Credit Card Promotion Points (Incorrectly In Many Cases)

January 27, 2023
Iberia Plus Has Moved To Revenue Based Program For Tickets Issued On Or After November 29, 2022

Reader Email: Oneworld Airlines Unable To Pull Correct Iberia Plus Status?

January 27, 2023
Airfare of the Day –Business Class- SKYTEAM Madrid to Toronto from 1,374€

Airfare of the Day –Business Class- SKYTEAM Milan to Sao Paulo from 1,382€

January 27, 2023
Rumors Of Hyatt & MGM Hotels & Resorts Ending Tier Match Partnership In Mid-2023, Any Truth To That?

Rumors Of Hyatt & MGM Hotels & Resorts Ending Tier Match Partnership In Mid-2023, Any Truth To That?

January 24, 2023
LAST CALL: Hilton Honors Gold & Diamond Gifting For 2021 Activity

UPDATE: Hilton Honors “Tier Last Call 2023 Promotion“ January 1 – March 31, 2023 (Valid Worldwide?)

January 23, 2023
ADVERTISEMENT

Since 2011, we have been helping millions of visitors like you untangle travel loyalty programs for free upgrades, flights and hotel nights.

Facebook Twitter Youtube Instagram

Site Navigation

  • About LoyaltyLobby
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Airfares
  • Contact Us

Hotel Promotions

  • Accor
  • Hilton
  • IHG Rewards
  • Marriott
  • World of Hyatt

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Our free daily newsletter sends you the latest information on hotel and airline programs.

We do not share or sell email addresses.

Site & Contents ©2011-2023 LoyaltyLobby.com
Terms of Use & Privacy Policy

  • News
  • Hotel Promotions
    • Accor
    • Best Western
    • Choice
    • Fairmont
    • Hilton
    • IHG Rewards
    • Marriott
    • Radisson Rewards
    • Ritz-Carlton
    • Starwood
    • World of Hyatt
    • Wyndham Rewards
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • Blog View
No Result
View All Result

© 2011–2023 LoyaltyLobby.com - Site & Contents